A paper company located on the banks of a river discharges its treated wastewater into the river. question which of the following would be the best control group to evaluate the treated wastewater from the paper company?

General
1

a paper company located on the banks of a river discharges its treated wastewater into the river. question which of the following would be the best control group to evaluate the treated wastewater from the paper company?

2

LectureNotes said a paper company located on the banks of a river discharges its treated wastewater into the river. Question: Which of the following would be the best control group to evaluate the treated wastewater from the paper company?

Answer: To evaluate the treated wastewater from the paper company effectively, selecting an appropriate control group is crucial. The control group should ideally represent the natural, unaffected state of the river to provide a baseline for comparison. Here are some potential control group options, with the best choice highlighted:

  1. A section of the river upstream from the discharge point: This is the most suitable control group. The water upstream is not influenced by the paper company’s wastewater discharge, thus representing the natural state of the river. Comparing the water quality parameters (such as pH, dissolved oxygen, chemical contaminants, and biological indicators) upstream and downstream of the discharge point will help determine the impact of the treated wastewater.

  2. A section of the river downstream from the discharge point: This is not a suitable control group because it is already affected by the discharged wastewater. It would not provide a baseline for the natural state of the river.

  3. A different river in a nearby region: While this might seem like a good control, it may not be ideal due to potential differences in the environmental conditions, pollution sources, and water chemistry between the two rivers. These differences could confound the results.

  4. A section of the river at a different time of year: This approach is less effective because seasonal variations in water quality could influence the results. Comparing water samples from different times of the year might not accurately reflect the impact of the wastewater discharge.

Therefore, the best control group to evaluate the treated wastewater from the paper company is a section of the river upstream from the discharge point. This approach ensures that the control group is representative of the natural state of the river, providing a clear basis for assessing the impact of the wastewater.