What is the difference in meaning between the two statements?
Answer:
The question presents two statements relating to Ahmet Haşim’s view on poetry, and it asks for the difference in meaning between them.
-
Comparison of Two Statements:
- Statement I: “Ahmet Haşim’e göre, şiir sanatların en güzelidir.” (According to Ahmet Haşim, poetry is the most beautiful of the arts.)
- Statement II: “Ahmet Haşim’in dediği gibi, şiir sanatların en güzelidir.” (As Ahmet Haşim said, poetry is the most beautiful of the arts.)
-
Analyzing the Meaning:
-
Statement I uses the phrase “Ahmet Haşim’e göre,” which directly attributes the opinion to Ahmet Haşim. It presents the idea as Haşim’s view.
-
Statement II uses “Ahmet Haşim’in dediği gibi,” which suggests that the speaker is quoting or referencing Ahmet Haşim’s words, possibly indicating an agreement with the statement.
-
-
Options Analysis:
-
Option A: Suggests that the second statement carries a more definitive judgment. However, this is not necessarily the case as both convey strong personal views.
-
Option B: Indicates an agreement with Ahmet Haşim’s view in the second statement. This isn’t explicitly indicated through the phrase used.
-
Option C: Notes that the second statement clarifies that the thought is Ahmet Haşim’s, which aligns with its structure.
-
Option D: States the first does not indicate agreement, while the second does imply shared sentiment—this indicates the inferred agreement present in the language of the second statement.
-
Option E: Suggests that additional judgments are incorporated in the first statement about Haşim’s opinion—inaccurate as both straightforwardly present the view as of Ahmet Haşim.
-
-
Final Assessment:
- Correct Option: C - “İkincisinde bu düşüncenin Ahmet Haşim’e olduğu belirtilmiştir.” (In the second, it is indicated that this thought belongs to Ahmet Haşim.)
Final Answer:
The correct answer is C: The second statement clarifies that the idea is attributed to Ahmet Haşim.